Good morning,
Sorry for the lack of activity lately, I've had coursework due in, and lots of stuff to catch up on since I was away most of last week at NUS conference. I've written something for Hullfire on it, so I'm being lazy and just going to post that on here instead. If you already know about conference, then the bit at the end is just comment from me, rather than news. Other than that, all is well. I'm in the International Students Association, Culture night on Saturday. We've written a 10 minute play and I'm a morris dancer. says it all really. should be good anyhow. Jamae and Cathy, who I met in China are hopefully coming over for that. Happy birthday to Lewis, sorry I couldn't make it to Loughborough. Big Jam meeting today, titled: "how can we do better". looking forward to it. john
Hulls students attend NUS conference
7 Hull students and sabbaticals attended the National Union of Students’ conference in Blackpool in week 8. The four-day event is also the Annual General Meeting of the union and sees motions debated and elections held for most positions. Nearly all Higher Education (Universities) and Further Education (Colleges) are represented at the conference, with a total of 1100 delegates attending.
Hull students who attended were Ross Old (education & representation elect), Mark Rich, Mike Duowona (Hull President) Sam Cunnington (Vice-president of Services), Emily Georgio (Vice-president education & welfare), Emma Hewitt and John Cumbers. The president of the union is automatically entitled to a place at conference, the other students were elected as conference delegates in the cross-campus elections in week 5, in which any student could stand.
Evening entertainment was provided, a disco the first night, casino and games the second and a party at Flares in Blackpool to finish the conference on Wednesday night. Late night drinking continued in Hotel bars along the sea-front.
Each delegate is put up in a hotel with meals included. The cost of the conference is taken from Hull Student Unions’ affiliation fees to the NUS, which is currently about £20 000. The total cost of the conference to the NUS is £300 000.
Mandy Telford, previously President of the Scottish NUS, won the election for President of the NUS and takes over from Owain James. Also worth noting are that Verity Coil President of Lincoln University (previously Humberside) won the election for the position of Student Welfare Officer. Two ex-Hull students were president at the conference, Craig Beamont, ex-Union Secretary Treasurer now on NUS Finance Committee, and Jenny Willmott, Ex-President now working on the NUS training team.
What was debated?
Different Universities can submit different motions to debate beforehand, and any amendments that they wish to see from those motions can also be debated. This is given to each delegate in a booklet, along with financial statements and reports at the start of conference. The Motions are then debated throughout the four days, in between reports, elections and formalities. Debates get extremely heated with much heckling and jeering from the conference floor. Much time wasting occurs in an attempt to stifle debate, with procedural motions for re-counts, and no-confidencing of the chair, which rotates between current executive committee members.
A full-time Black Students Officer was ratified this year. This had been passed the previous year, but as it involved a new paid position it needed to be ratified by two conferences in a row before it became policy. Under NUS constitution, any student can define themselves as black, so the role supports all minority groups.
A total of six motions were debated. Two big motions chosen for debate this year were Education Funding and Reform of the NUS. Due to time wasting, three other motions were not debated. Conference agreed the governments handling of student funding was not working, and that a graduate tax was not a fair way to tax students for education, and that the government should be lobbied not to implement this idea. An amendment to launch “a bold and militant campaign of mass action” against the tax was however rejected.
The reform debate progressed slowly, the National Treasurer Gerraint Owen, called the national Conference a dinosaur. He said it cost too much and proposed to cut costs by reducing numbers of delegates. It was voted on to cut the number of delegates by one third. Many other reforms did not get passed due to factional in-fighting.
Emergency debates were requested for current topics, such as bombing Iraq and the Israeli occupation of Palestinian land. Some student’s present believed that the NUS should oppose both of the above and that it should be campaigning on those issues. Others believe that they do not affect students and that the NUS should not be involved with them. There was, however, no time for these to be debated, some argued that time had deliberately been wasted to prevent the issues being discusses. In protest , towards the end of conference, a group of about 25 students, wearing Palestinian head scarves and chanting slogans, occupied the stage, before being asked to sit down again, which they eventually did.
Hull delegates said they enjoyed the experience but the political factions within the NUS and the blatant time wasting during debates were frustrating. Hull Union is not particularly a political one, and there are very few active political parties. Other University unions have much stronger links with political parties.
Box
What is the NUS and how does it work?
The National Union of Students provides training and support to all student unions through-out the country. Some student unions are more involved than others. It has a regional representative and office for the north-east who give the sabbaticals, the students who run our union at Hull, help and advice. The NUS also campaigns on issues which affect students, these issues are chosen and debated at the national conference.
The NUS is a democratic body, with a written constitution, elections for most positions and formal procedures for debate. The current climate however, is highly political and many factions exist amongst the students which attend conference, such as Labour students, Conservative Future, Socialist workers, Broad Left, to name a few. Political parties encourage student members to take an active interest in the NUS and many fund their election campaigns. Mandy Telford, the new president is part of the Labour Student’s movement.
Box:
A waste of time and money? by John Cumbers, Hull conference delegate 2002.
If you’ve ever been to Hull’s Union Council, and thought it was bureaucratic and boring, then times it by 20, throw in some heckling and a bit of jeering, a few more votes of no confidence and a couple of student activists and you have the NUS Annual Conference. Oh, did I forget to say it costs £300 000 more than Union Council as well?
The first time I heard of conference was in my first year, when I came to vote and saw the position up for grabs on the ballot paper. I didn’t know much about it then, and I still new nothing about it when I stood for the position in this years elections, but I thought it would be a good opportunity to find out.
So we arrive in Blackpool, Hull t-shirts donned and I’m still getting over the fact that none of us in the minibus have had any arguments yet - being the political types who have chosen to go and talk shop for four days. In fact the whole weekend seemed to act as a bonding session, despite the fact that half the delegates were sabbaticals leaving next year but everyone got on really well. So, Blackpool, half tacky, half great, not been before but pleasantly surprised, as long as I steered clear of the donkey rides, giant Parrots, “Louix Tousaud’s” wax works (I wonder which is the rip-off), and sewage on the beach. A genuinely nice place to unwind, and I ended the week feeling really refreshed, despite the lack of actually debating anything constructive.
The hotel was wicked, great food, great staff, great sea view from my window, swimming pool, pool table (now with a Pepsi stain on it -Georghio!) and a bar that stayed open till there’s no one left drinking. A bit far from the conference, but hey, the tram outside would get you there for a pound, or a 25 minute walk along the seafront.
So a holiday then? A four day-long piss-up at everyone else’s expense? Well, sort of, but not totally. It certainly wasn’t the average delegates fault if they ended up wasting their time. All of our delegation spent nearly all of their time on the conference floor during the debates, many perhaps conscious of the fact that I’d shame them in Hullfire if they didn’t. But after one day of conference, the novelty value of another re-count or vote of no confidence really does wear off, as people clamour to the front and scribbling notes to the chair to slow the procedures down. The dinosaur of debate plods on through the bureaucratic motions, and slowly but surely the seats on the conference floor thin out. On Wednesday morning it took an hour just to get quorate (the number of people needed to vote). By the last day, perhaps 50% pf people had jacked it in to go to the pleasure beach, or ride a donkey perhaps. Or maybe I’m too cynical and they were just off preparing speeches?
If I’ve learnt anything from the conference, it’s that reform of any large organisation takes time. I still hold the opinion that I held before conference that the majority of students do not understand the meaning of the word Union, or know what students’ unions are for. Most have a basic lack of knowledge of how democracy works and when they show some interest, they are bombarded with rules, regulations and political factions, enough to turn anyone off. Communication is needed if we want to change this, we need to bring people on-board through openness, something which the NUS, and our Union both lack. If you want to get students going, then tell them what’s going on, give them the opportunity to get involved and don’t wrap everything you do in red tape.
Before conference I thought we had politics in our union. Yes we have debate and democracy, but thankfully we don’t have polarisation of views or political factions. Lets try and keep it that way. This is our chance for us to work together and actually achieve really great things, without the politics getting into it. The next step is to stop talking about it and get on with it, so I’ll shut up now.

